Religion – Opium for the Folk?

540661986_fcd819fc3b_z

India’s crux

There are more poverty stricken people in India than in all Sub-Saharan countries combined. Almost half of the children below the age of five are malnourished on the subcontinent. The most illiterate people live here. An estimated half of households do not have sanitary facilities. The list goes ad infinitum.

However, the GDP has been growing for years. Increasingly more people suffer from obesity in cities, and corrupt politicians as well as others are stashing apparently trillions of dollars on foreign accounts. Simply put: India is (excuse my language) a literally bloody unequal country.

Why does it not take people to the streets in order to demand change and equality? Or only if an old man starves himself almost to death? Millions of people could make a change, history has proven.

German political atheism

The German philosophers Ludwig Feuerbach and Karl Marx would probably answer that one of the main reasons for political stupefaction is religion. According to Feuerbach, men has an instinct of self-preservation (Selbsterhaltungstrieb), which is intimately linked to an urge for beatitude (Glückseligkeitstrieb).

Since this urge for happiness is encumbered by nature and society, men tries to compensate the resulting feeling of dependence by creating religion with the help of fantasy. Even though this gives a certain relief to the human, it distracts from problems which we encounter here and now, argues Feuerbach. Even worse: men becomes disunited with himself.

Rather than religion, we are supposed to focus our attention on interpersonal relationships. Homo homini deus est (men is supposed to become a god to men) is his mantra.

The early Marx, who was heavily influences in his thinking by Feuerbach, famously said: „It [religion] is opium for the folk.“ For him religion was an illusionary, heavenly panacea for earthly suffering. A distraction from political suppression and social degradation. Especially through the fictional promise of salvation in the netherworld, which takes the power of changing actual matters in this world.

After Marx religion is even an instrument of political ideology, an instrumentum regni. Maybe it is not all that wrong to become suspicious as soon as a political party turns religion to the core of their identity.

Looking at the Indian society, Feuerbach and Marx seem to have a point. It is not only the belief in afterlife, but also the misconception of karma and continuing adherence to an antediluvian cast system that creates political paralysis.

Religion as political power

Although I see some truth in the argument of the German philosophers, I want to militate against it. An atheistic world, or rather a world without out any metaphysics, without being beyond matter and empirical data, will not create a better world.

Not only because the human has, as I believe, a metaphysical basic need. Even for much more pragmatic reasons, which I will not be able to elaborate now and partly have mentioned before. (By the way this does not per se mean religion in its ancient, often parochial forms has to persist, but a way of living that is not ignorant of the complexity of being.)

Instead, I want to argue that we should use religion in order to make it more political, so exactly vice versa to Feuerbach’s and Marx’s conception – an instrumentum populi. Of course, this does not mean one should – and I am aware one is endangered to – misuse old, dusty scriptures and arguments to legitimate „holy wars”, abortions or suchlike, oblivious of counterarguments.

I am talking about taking religious stories, sagas, thoughts, and wisdoms as an inspiration and impetus for debate and, on the long run, for action. For the struggles that people have undergone millennia ago are often merely different on their outer appearance. And what is religion but the memorials thereof?

For example, did Moses not lead his people from virtual slavery and repression to freedom? Did the Pandavas not fight against the Kauravas in order to regain what was rightfully theirs? The narrative well of religion is fathomless.

Have you ever encountered on these pages a protagonist, who slothfully sits on the sofa waiting for afterlife to take care of his problems? Barely. Most of them speak, act and die for the putative better.

Hence, do not forget Moksha, Djanna, heaven, or whatever you may call it, but do not make it an excuse for your present idleness. Listen to the political and social messages you can find in between the divine letters, instigate debate, and take it, if necessary, to the streets.

Yet, (and I do know I reiterate myself) do not copy and paste sentences uncritically into your perception of the world, as there is a thin line between the fundamentalist and the righteous.

 

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Religion – Opium for the Folk?

  1. Hello, I think you probably said it correctly . But is it really a need of religion? Can’t we took an alternative one?

    Sorry in advance, if I took it wrong .

  2. Never apologize for asking.
    As I briefly mentioned, it does not necessarily have to be religion, but a way of living that is not oblivious of the manifold metaphysical ways of being. We live in a time where everything tends to get reduced to the material, the empirical, the data, something that has and will have disastrous effects in plenty of ways.
    Further, if religion is so enshrined in the hearts of Indian people, I would try to implement it for the better instead of radically doing away with it, for it has a an essential part to it, which acknowledges being beyond here and now – although it has perilous characteristics, which I do not deny.
    Thanks for your input.
    All the best
    Krisha

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s